Professor of the Social Studies of Science and Technology, Sherry
Turkle, takes a strong position on the effects of technology on today's
conversations. In her recent opinion article in The New York Times,
Stop Googling. Let's Talk, Turkle focuses on how the age-old
face-to-face conversation is being replaced by text messages and the
distraction of the cell phone. With careful analyzation of the human
race, she draws the conclusion that our capability of holding a conversation is
worsening as a result of everyday technology. Through "studying the
psychology of online connectivity for more than 30 years", she includes a number of different resources in her article,
ranging from children to college students. In one of the mentioned
studies, a team at the University of Michigan "found a 40 percent decline
in empathy among college students, with most of the decline taking place after
2000". By including this research in her text, Turkle appeals to
logos by providing scientific proof to her audience. This shows that
there is more than just daily observations and scenarios supporting her claim.
Sherry Turkle
also utilizes satire in her writing, not only targeting the "digital
generation" but also including herself in the accusation.
Throughout her article, she constantly uses the words "we" and
"our". For example, she states that "we've gotten used to
being connected all the time, but we have found ways around conversation".
This point of view in which she is satirizing not only forces the reader
to admit to themselves that they value time on their phone more than genuine
discussion with somebody, but it also establishes a sense of credibility about
herself. It makes the reader feel less criticized, but still has the
effect that it needs in order to make the audience find fault with themselves.
Turkle also does this in an effort to show the reader how almost
everybody can be impacted by these side effects of text messaging and
apps; she doesn't try to put herself on some type of pedestal.
Through the use
of these rhetorical strategies, Turkle is successfully able to make her
audience aware of the consequences of relying too much on technology for
communication. However, at the end of her article, she makes clear that
"we are not looking for simple solutions" but instead, "we are
looking for beginnings". She then goes on to give suggestions on how
to possibly begin improving face-to-face conversation, and how sometimes we
just need to be put ourselves in an uncomfortable situation; starting a
conversation can be risky. But her point is that without that risk
factor, it's becoming more difficult for us to find ourselves.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/27/opinion/sunday/stop-googling-lets-talk.html?ref=opinion&_r=0
No comments:
Post a Comment